Well, I’ve finally gotten a completed order from Fastenal.com. It took over a month to ship because one of the washers (the largest, I think) had to be special ordered and the company was very bad about communicating this to me (it took an irate email threatening to cancel my order before I got a response that let me know what was going on). Also, the original order was short 11 of the 1” washers, but had a couple of extra 2” and 1 extra 3” washer, a probable result of them dealing with quantity on a by weight basis rather than actually counting. They were very good, however, about fixing the short and said I could keep the extras. Clearly they’re used to supplying contractors who could care less about a couple of washers here or there since their ordering in 100’s or even 1000’s usually. Given the price, and the avaialbility of such unusually large sizes, my recommendation is that orders of the more common sizes (1” and 2") be seperated from orders of the larger, uncommon sizes (3” and above) and that you allow plenty of lead time when ordering the larger sizes.
Furthermore, the larger sizes (3” and above) are clearly thought of as machine parts as they came with a grease residue on them that I had to wash off. Not exactly a hard thing to do, but it was unexpected.
The washers themselves, however, are great. I’ve attached photos. The first is a stack of each washer size from the 1” on top to the 5” on bottom. The second gives you a better feel for the size of the 5”. That’s a 2” washer inside the 5” washer and there are 5 1” washers across the bottom (the slight fisheye look is the result of using a web cam at closer than the recommended distance). I can’t wait for my players to reach a level where I can put that 5” washer into play.
On another note, I’m going to be experimenting with various finishes for the completed tokens in an attempt to make them dry erase friendly (i.e. you can write on them with dry erase markers and erase it later). Any one have any suggestions for what might work?

Click thumbnail to see full-size image